Creating space for healing in Milwaukee

 

Redeemer Lutheran Church brings mental health care, meals and housing together

At Redeemer Lutheran Church on Milwaukee’s Near West Side, neighbors come for lunch and leave with more—counseling, essential supplies, even a sameday shower and clean clothes.  

By design, Redeemer provides community meals, onsite mental health and substance use assistance, and housing navigation under one roof so help is easy to find.  

With support from a Mission Investment Fund (MIF) loan Redeemer renovated its 1917 building to support this integrated approach: counselors eat upstairs with guests, allowing relationships to build and grow naturally. A drop-in clinic sits just downstairs, along with showers, private restrooms and space for partners to meet people face-to-face.  

The congregation chose this path after a tragic death on its front steps in 2019 revealed how urgently neighbors needed accessible local care. 

A downtown church making a difference  

“We’ve always been a city church that includes everyone, from some of the wealthiest to people who sleep outside with nothing to claim,” explains the Rev. Lisa Bates-Froiland. She served as Redeemer’s pastor from 2011 until the conclusion of her call earlier this year. “From the start, we’ve tried to be diverse. That legacy continues in every way we can imagine God’s welcoming genius.” 

From community meals to hosting civic meetings and housing offices for the Interfaith Conference of Greater Milwaukee, Redeemer serves as a neighborhood anchor. “Our location is a gift, so our response is to bless the community in every way we can.” 

How the model works  

Olga Neighborhood Wellness Services, a separate nonprofit established by the congregation, coordinates the meal program and key partnerships, including Serenity Inns, which operates a drop-in clinic for mental health and substance use disorder counseling on Redeemer’s lower level.  

More than 300 people receive meals at Redeemer Lutheran in a typical week. Lunches, served one day a week before renovations, are now available on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Sundays. Serenity Inns’ counselors often meet people first over lunch. 

When someone is ready, they can continue the conversation downstairs at the clinic, building on that trust in a more private setting. “This is what we dreamed of,” says Pastor Bates-Froiland.  

“Addressing mental health or substance use is brave and hard. Trust takes time. A regular meal, plus the presence of staff from the church and Serenity create multiple touchpoints so people can say, ‘I trust the clinic at Redeemer.’”  

Olga also meets neighbors where they are. Soap and a toothbrush. A change of clothes. A shower and a load of laundry. Four walls and a door in the restroom. At Olga, dignity isn’t abstract; it’s built into the basics.  

Partnering with Bread of Healing Clinic and the Milwaukee County Housing Division, Olga helps neighbors pursue health care, long-term stability and a safe place to live. 

Meeting people during the meal makes a noticeable difference, supporting meaningful conversations about options.  

Redeemer Lutheran Church has been recognized by neighborhood associations, the Red Cross and others for its impact in the community. The improved space makes more possible for the people Redeemer serves.

MIF: A deep understanding of how churches operate  

Redeemer had planned to pay for renovations without borrowing, but as bids came back with firm deadlines, expenses climbed and the project grew more complex.  

Faced with a choice—pause the work or take a loan to finish on schedule—the congregation partnered with MIF.  

“We already had a term investment with MIF, so we were familiar with MIF and how investments with MIF fund loans,” says Pastor Bates-Froiland. That familiarity mattered—and so did the terms, especially the no prepayment penalty, which meant early campaign gifts and larger ongoing gifts could go straight to principal.  

“MIF’s flexibility, especially the no prepayment penalty on loans, and a deep understanding of how churches operate tipped the scales in MIF’s favor,” says Pastor Bates-Froiland.  

A new chapter  

With construction complete, Redeemer will be reinvigorating support groups and all-ages Sunday school, expanding lay leadership and deepening ties with Marquette University students. The congregation began with community first; now it turns toward congregational growth while sustaining its integrated care model. 

“Our leadership is actively dreaming; the next pastor will help shape congregational ministries,” Pastor Bates-Froiland shares.  

Dignity for all  

Redeemer Lutheran Church is a highly regarded institution in the city. But what matters most is the neighbor who came for a meal and was overwhelmed by the dignity and respect they received as they were listened to and seen as a whole person.  

Shares Pastor Bates-Froiland: “Our mission is to live out the gospel here, because as we think about how Jesus interacted with everyone he met, that's our goal too.”

Investments

Loans